Divorce Settlement Analysis: Four Ontario Case Studies

See how four fair-looking offers played out over twenty years, and how a settlement analysis tests yours before you sign.

Last reviewed: October 23, 2026 by Ken S. Maynard, AP.fm, CDFA

A divorce settlement analysis shows you what an offer will do to your life, year by year, before you agree to it. A split that’s equal on paper can still leave one of you out of money ten years later. The four Ontario case studies below show how that happens, and what changed the outcome.

None of these couples is a real family. Each one is a composite, built from a pattern I see again and again in my files: one spouse with the income or the pension, one who stepped back, and an offer that looks fair until someone runs it forward.

What it is

A year-by-year projection of your settlement

Who it’s for

One spouse, or both of you in mediation

What you get

A plain-language report for you and your lawyer

When to do it

Before you sign anything

The four case studies

Each case starts with an offer the paying spouse honestly believed was fair. Then we run it forward and see who’s still standing at 65.

The 50/50 Split That Left One Spouse Broke

Paul and Sara split about $1.6 million down the middle after 20 years of marriage. Sara took the house. Paul kept the RRSP and the investments. On paper it was even. Run forward, Sara’s spendable savings were gone by about age 45, while Paul’s kept growing every year.

The lesson: an equal split of property isn’t the same as an equal outcome. Read the 50/50 split case study.

Keeping the House Is the Most Expensive Decision in Your Separation

Bob and Cindy have two young children. Cindy wanted to keep the family home, and Bob said his three-year-old business shouldn’t count. The house cost about $40,000 a year to carry, with no job income behind it, and her savings ran out by 40. Better terms only bought her two more years. Selling the house and moving into their rental property changed her savings at 65 from nothing to about $2.46 million in future dollars.

The lesson: a house is a bill that happens to have equity in it. Read the keeping-the-house case study, or test your own numbers with our free Matrimonial Home Buyout Calculator.

Half of $3.4 Million and Still Broke at 70

After 30 years, Doug kept his pension and Rose kept the house. The two halves were worth about the same. But Doug’s pension pays him about $99,000 a year for life, and Rose’s house pays her nothing. Under his offer, her savings were empty at 70. Raising spousal support did more for her future than any change to the property split.

The lesson: a pension is an income, not a lump sum. Read the pension division case study.

Four Properties, One Exemption: What Wealthy Couples Miss

Andrew and Mary were worth just over $7.3 million, including four properties. About $1.4 million of that was tax nobody had paid yet, partly because only one home can be sheltered from capital gains tax. Under Andrew’s first offer, Mary’s savings were empty at 63, even though she still owned two properties worth more than $2 million.

The lesson: wealth delays the problem, it doesn’t prevent it. Read the high net worth case study.

Is there an offer on the table right now?

Book a free 15-minute call and we’ll talk about whether a settlement analysis fits your situation.

What all four cases have in common

The details change from family to family. These five problems don’t, and none of them shows up on a list of assets:

  • Not every dollar can be spent. A house is worth a lot, costs money every month and pays you nothing.

  • Not every dollar is the same size. RRSPs, pensions and second properties carry tax that hasn’t been paid yet.

  • Spousal support often matters more than the property split. In Doug and Rose’s case, the support number decided almost everything.

  • Better terms can’t fix a broken structure. Moving debt around bought Cindy two years. Changing where she lived changed her life.

  • Earning capacity is the biggest asset nobody lists. Years of future income were built during the marriage, and they don’t get divided.

A balance sheet shows what each of you owns on the day you separate. A settlement analysis shows what each of you will have coming in and going out every year after that.

Two ways to get a settlement analysis

I do this work as a Certified Divorce Financial Analyst, and it runs two ways. The method and the report are the same. What changes is who I’m working for.

For one spouse For both of you in mediation
Who hires me You, on your own Both of you, together
Who sees the report You and your lawyer Both of you, the same report
Does your spouse need to take part? No Yes
Best when You’ve been handed an offer, or you’re about to make one You’re in mediation and want one set of numbers
What it shows Both spouses’ futures, so you can tell if the deal holds Both futures side by side, so you can trade knowingly

Most often I’m retained by one person. You don’t need your spouse’s cooperation, you don’t need to be in mediation, and you don’t need to have decided how you’ll separate. Choose your route at the start, though. Once I’ve had a material conversation with one of you as a CDFA, I can’t act for both of you.

When couples do it together, the conversation usually changes. “This doesn’t feel fair” is easy to brush off. “I run out of money at 45, and here’s the line” isn’t. And the paying spouse often isn’t trying to do harm. Once they see the chart, many of them move.

What the analysis does, and what it doesn’t

I take your financial statements and the offer on the table, plus the realistic alternatives, and run them forward year by year for both of you. You see cash flow, savings, net worth and tax. You see what happens when support ends, when the children finish school and at 65. Then you get it in plain language, with the options side by side.

I don’t decide what spousal support should be, I don’t value pensions or businesses, and I don’t do your tax return. Those belong to your lawyer, the pension plan administrator, a business valuator and your accountant. I take their numbers and show you what each combination of them produces.

The reports are built with Settlement Projection Advisor, a settlement analysis tool we developed around Ontario financial statements and the net family property calculation (the total each spouse gained during the marriage, which decides who owes whom). It models both spouses at once and handles the tax on RRSPs and pensions properly. It will be available to other family professionals from January 15, 2027.

Ken S. Maynard, AP.fm, CDFA

Ken S. Maynard, AP.fm, CDFA

Ken has run settlement analyses for Ontario families as a Certified Divorce Financial Analyst since 2010. He doesn’t decide what support should be, and he doesn’t give legal advice. About Ken.

How a settlement analysis works

  1. Get Acquainted Call. A free 15-minute call by phone or video to see whether the analysis fits your situation.

  2. Gather your numbers. Your Form 13.1 financial statement (the sworn statement of income, expenses, property and debts used in Ontario family cases), or the information that goes into one. If you haven’t put it together yet, we help.

  3. Model the options. I run the offer on the table and the realistic alternatives forward, usually to retirement and past it.

  4. Get your report. Plain language, with each option side by side for both spouses.

  5. Use it. Take it to your lawyer, or bring it into mediation, before anything is signed.

Reading keeps you informed. Talking helps you feel better.

If you’ve read everything and still don’t know your next step, let’s talk it through in a free, no-pressure call.

Settlement analysis: common questions

What is a divorce settlement analysis?

It’s a year-by-year projection of what a proposed settlement does to each spouse’s cash flow, savings and net worth

It takes your financial statements and the terms on the table and runs them forward, often to retirement and beyond. It shows what happens when support ends, when the children finish school and when either of you retires.

The point is to compare options before you agree to one, so the decision is made with the numbers in front of you.

Does a settlement analysis replace legal advice?

No. It’s financial analysis, and your lawyer still gives you the legal advice

I don’t tell you what spousal support should be or what to accept. The analysis gives you and your lawyer a clear picture of what each option produces, so the legal advice rests on real numbers instead of guesses.

Can I get a settlement analysis if my spouse won’t take part?

Yes. Most of the time I’m retained by one spouse alone

The analysis is stronger when both financial statements are complete. Even so, a one-sided analysis still tells you whether the offer in front of you holds up.

Can we do a settlement analysis together as a couple?

Yes. In mediation I run one analysis for both of you and present one report

You both see the same projections, built on the same assumptions, before you agree to anything. Most couples find it easier to settle once they can see what each option does to the other person, not only to themselves.

If you run the analysis for me, can you still mediate for us later?

No. Once I’ve had a material conversation with one of you as a CDFA, I can’t act for both of you

Mediation needs someone who is neutral between you. Once I’ve worked through your situation with one spouse, I can’t be that person for the couple.

If you think you may want to mediate together, say so on your Get Acquainted Call, before you share the details of your situation. Then we can pick the right route from the start.

When should a settlement analysis be done?

Before anything is signed, while the options are still open

An analysis run early can change the settlement. One run after signing only explains what happened, and a signed separation agreement in Ontario is hard and expensive to reopen.

How far into the future does a settlement analysis look?

Usually to retirement and past it, because most of the damage shows up years later

In the case studies above, the trouble rarely appears in year one. It appears the year support ends, when the children finish school or at 65. A model that stops at five years misses most of the story.

What do you need from me to run a settlement analysis?

Your Form 13.1 financial statement, or the information that goes into one

That means income, expenses, assets, debts, and their values at the date of marriage and the date of separation. If you haven’t pulled that together yet, it’s part of what we help with.

Are the couples in these case studies real people?

No. Each couple is a composite built from patterns that come up often in practice

The names, ages and numbers are invented so no client can be identified. The patterns are real, and so is the math behind each projection.

High Net Worth Separation in Ontario: The Tax Inside Your Assets

Four Properties, One Exemption: What Wealthy Couples Miss A $7.3 million estate split evenly still left one spouse out of money at 63. Here's the tax and cost nobody counted. Book a free Get Acquainted [...]

High Net Worth Separation in Ontario: The Tax Inside Your Assets2026-10-29T22:36:51-04:00