Illustration of a financial analyst and client reviewing a divorce settlement analysis at a desk

Settlement Analysis: What Your Divorce Settlement Is Really Worth

Before you sign, see what each term is worth after tax, what two households will cost, and where the deal could fail. For one spouse, or for both of you in mediation.

Last reviewed: October 25, 2026 by Ken S. Maynard, AP.fm, CDFA

The service

The Settlement Stress Test: a written report and a review meeting

The fee

$2,500 plus HST, flat, when one spouse retains me

In mediation

Included for both of you at no extra fee

The analyst

Ken S. Maynard, CDFA since 2010

A separation agreement can look fair on paper and still leave one of you short every month. Equal isn’t the same as equivalent. A $300,000 RRSP and a $300,000 house are both $300,000 until you try to spend them. Settlement analysis is the work of checking the numbers before they’re final.

I’m Ken Maynard, a Certified Divorce Financial Analyst (CDFA). I’ve done this work in Ontario since 2010, for one spouse at a time and for couples in mediation. This page explains what the analysis is, who it’s for, what you get, what it costs and how to start.

Settlement analysis is one part of divorce financial planning. My book sorts the money side of a separation into three horizons: Now, protecting your cash, housing and bills while things are unsettled; Soon, preparing and testing the settlement; and Later, the life that follows it. Settlement analysis is the Soon work: it tests the deal before you sign. If you’re not at the offer stage yet, start with the planning guide.

Is settlement analysis for you?

It’s for you if any of these sound familiar:

  • You have an offer in hand, from your spouse or from a lawyer, and a knot in your stomach about it.

  • You’re in mediation and want the numbers tested as you go, not after you’ve agreed.

  • You’re deciding whether to keep the house, take the pension, or trade one for the other.

  • One of you managed the money, and the other needs to understand the picture before agreeing to anything.

  • You own a business, have stock options or a rental property, or support will be a large part of the settlement.

It isn’t legal advice, and it doesn’t replace your lawyer. It tells you what the deal is worth, so that when your lawyer reviews the agreement, you both know what you’re looking at.

What you get: the Settlement Stress Test

The analysis is delivered as a written report and a review meeting. I call it the Settlement Stress Test, after the 12 checks in my book, Divorce the Smartway: Think Beyond the Settlement. The report covers:

  • Your equalization calculation, checked line by line against the financial disclosure.

  • Each option restated at its after-tax value, so an RRSP, a house and a cash payment are compared on the same footing.

  • A year-one budget for each household, built on the support and the assets in the proposal.

  • Five-, ten- and twenty-year projections of where each of you lands.

  • The weak points: the terms that could fail the test, and at least one way to fix each of them.

  • A one-page summary for each of your lawyers.

The 12 checks

Every proposal is run through the same twelve questions. Each one is a place where a settlement that looks fine on paper can fail in real life.

  1. Asset value. Are the values current, supported and measured on the correct date?

  2. Tax. What taxes are embedded now or later, and who will bear them?

  3. Liquidity. How much usable cash will I actually have after closing?

  4. Debt. What debt will remain in my name, and what monthly payment follows it?

  5. Cash flow. Does the post-settlement monthly budget work with realistic expenses?

  6. Housing. Can I qualify for and sustainably carry the housing arrangement?

  7. Support. What support is assumed, for how long, with what tax and variation risk?

  8. Children. What table support, section 7 and post-secondary costs are foreseeable?

  9. Retirement. What happens to pension and retirement income under the proposal?

  10. Risk. Which risks am I accepting: market, payment, interest-rate, longevity, business or tax risk?

  11. Implementation. Can every transfer, refinance, sale and payment actually be completed?

  12. Flexibility. What happens if income, health, housing or family circumstances change?

The report also tests the proposal in three time horizons: now (closing costs, deposits, moving costs and immediate bills), soon (the first one to three years, while support, housing and the children’s costs settle into a pattern) and later (mortgage renewal, retirement, the end of support and the children leaving home).

The projections come from the Settlement Projection Advisor, the tool I built for this work. Other professionals will be able to use it from January 15, 2027. Projections are projections, not guarantees. They show the direction and the size of the differences between options, which is what you need to decide.

Two ways to work with me

Retained by one spouse

Most often one spouse retains me. I work for you. I review the proposal, build the scenarios, and give you the report and the review meeting. Your lawyer gets the one-page summary. The fee is $2,500 plus HST, flat.

As a neutral for both of you, in mediation

Inside Soft Landing Mediation the analysis is part of the process, at no extra fee. I owe the same duty to each of you and say so in writing before the work starts. Both of you see the same scenarios, which is usually what moves a couple from arguing about the numbers to deciding between them.

One rule to know before you call: once I’ve had a real conversation with one of you as a CDFA, I can’t act for both. If you want the neutral version, decide that together, then book one call for the two of you.

How it works

  1. A free Get Acquainted Call. Fifteen minutes, by phone or video. You tell me where you are. I tell you whether the analysis will help and what it would show.

  2. Disclosure and the proposal. You send the financial statements, the offer or draft agreement, and any support calculations. If you’re not sure what counts as disclosure, the Form 13 guide and The Divorce Disclosure Handbook list it.

  3. The analysis. I check the equalization, build the scenarios, run the projections and write the report. How long it takes depends on the file. I give you a date on the call.

  4. The review meeting. We go through the report together, by video or in person. You leave with the report, the summary for your lawyer, and a clear view of what to accept, what to change and what to ask for.

What it costs, and what it doesn’t include

The Settlement Stress Test is $2,500 plus HST, flat, for the analysis and the review meeting when one spouse retains me. In Soft Landing Mediation it’s included at no extra fee.

It doesn’t include:

  • Appraisals of the home or other property.

  • The Family Law Value statement for a pension. The plan administrator prepares it, and FSRA caps the fee at $200 for a defined contribution plan, $600 for a defined benefit plan and $800 for a combined plan, plus HST.

  • A business valuation by a Chartered Business Valuator.

  • Legal advice. Your lawyer reviews the agreement before you sign.

For comparison, asking a lawyer to run settlement scenarios at $400 an hour is the wrong tool for the job, and it costs more. The analysis can pay for itself if it prevents one costly mistake, and first offers usually contain at least one term that doesn’t survive the test.

What settlement analysis isn’t

  • Not legal advice. Your lawyer advises on your rights and reviews the agreement before you sign. If you don’t have one yet, start with the independent legal advice guide.

  • Not investment advice. I don’t sell products or manage money.

  • Not a guarantee. The projections rest on assumptions we agree on, and the report shows them.

Why I do this work

In 2007 I drafted my own separation agreement. It didn’t hold. The two and a half years in Ontario family court that followed cost about $85,000 in legal fees, and most of the fight came down to numbers nobody had tested. I earned the CDFA in 2010 and started this practice the same year, after 27 years as a financial, business and real estate analyst. Since then I’ve trained in family mediation, interest-based negotiation and high-conflict work, and written three books on the money side of separation. The Stress Test is the check I wish someone had run on my own agreement.

If you want the wider picture first, the divorce financial planning guide covers every money question in one place, and the tax implications of divorce explains why after-tax value matters so much.

Want the real number for your situation?

In a free call we’ll talk about your settlement and what the analysis would show. No retainer, no pressure.

Ken S. Maynard, AP.fm, CDFA

Ken S. Maynard, AP.fm, CDFA | Divorce the Smartway

Certified Divorce Financial Analyst since 2010 and accredited family mediator, with 15 years in practice helping Ontario families see the after-tax numbers behind their decisions. Member of FDRIO and co-founder of the Association of Private Family Mediators Canada. Author of three books, including Divorce the Smartway: Think Beyond the Settlement.

Reading keeps you informed. Talking helps you feel better.

If you have a settlement in front of you and you’re not sure about it, book a free Get Acquainted Call by phone or video.

Settlement analysis: common questions

Do I need settlement analysis if I already have a lawyer?

Often, yes. Your lawyer advises on your rights; the analysis shows what the deal is worth after tax and over time

Lawyers are trained in the law, not in running twenty-year cash flow projections, and most will tell you so. The two jobs fit together. You bring the report to your lawyer, and the review gets faster and more focused because the numbers are already on the table.

Can you do the analysis for both of us?

Yes, as a neutral inside mediation, as long as you both agree before I’ve spoken with either of you as a CDFA

Once I’ve had a real conversation with one spouse about the finances, I can’t act for both. If you want the shared version, decide together first and book one call for the two of you. Inside Soft Landing Mediation the analysis is included at no extra fee.

What do you need from me?

Your financial disclosure, the proposal or draft agreement, and any support calculations

That means the Form 13 or 13.1 Financial Statement if one exists, statements for your accounts, debts and pensions at the date of marriage and the date of separation, and the offer you’ve been given. The Divorce Disclosure Handbook and the Form 13 guide on this site list every document and where to find it.

How long does it take?

One offer usually takes a meeting or two from the time I have your documents; complex files take longer

A business, several properties or an unusual pension adds time. I give you a date on the Get Acquainted Call once I know what’s in the file.

What happens if the settlement fails the test?

You get the weak points in writing, with at least one way to fix each, so you can go back to your spouse or lawyer with numbers instead of a feeling

Failing the test isn’t unusual. It usually means one or two terms need to change, not that the whole deal is wrong. The report shows what each fix is worth so you can decide what’s worth asking for.

What does settlement analysis cost?

$2,500 plus HST, flat, for the analysis and the review meeting when one spouse retains me; included at no extra fee in Soft Landing Mediation

Appraisals, the pension Family Law Value statement, a business valuation and legal advice are separate. The section above lists what each of those costs.

Is this the same as divorce financial planning?

No. Settlement analysis is the Soon part of divorce financial planning, the part that tests a specific deal; planning also covers the Now and the Later

If you don’t have a proposal yet, start with the divorce financial planning guide, which answers every money question in one place. When there’s a deal on the table, the analysis is what tests it.

Do you work online?

Yes, by video anywhere in Ontario, or in person with a DTSW associate at our Greater Toronto centres

Most settlement analysis work is done by video. The documents are shared securely, and the review meeting works the same way on screen as across a table.

General information, not legal or tax advice. Fees current to October 2026. Projections depend on the assumptions in each report.