
Four Properties, One Exemption: What Wealthy Couples Miss
A $7.3 million estate split evenly still left one spouse out of money at 63. Here’s the tax and cost nobody counted.
Last reviewed: October 23, 2026 by Ken S. Maynard, AP.fm, CDFA
There’s a particular kind of separation where everyone relaxes too early.
The couple is wealthy. There’s a house, a cottage, investments, a pension. Nobody is worried about anybody ending up destitute. The lawyers focus on dividing things fairly and everybody goes home reasonably satisfied.
Then, ten years on, one spouse is selling property to pay for groceries.
This happens more than you’d think, for two reasons. High net worth estates carry a lot of tax that hasn’t been paid yet, and nobody counts it. And a portfolio of properties generates no income at all while costing a great deal to keep.
Andrew and Mary aren’t real people. They’re a composite of a pattern that turns up in almost every substantial file.
The couple
Married 30 years, ages 55 and 52
The estate
Just over $7.3 million, with four properties
Hidden tax
About $1.4 million not yet paid
The problem
Mary’s savings empty at 63 under his offer
Meet Andrew and Mary
Married 30 years. Andrew is 55, Mary is 52. The children are grown and gone.
Andrew earns $400,000 and takes home about $221,500. He has a defined benefit pension with a Family Law Value of $1.4 million, which will pay him roughly $105,000 a year, indexed, from 66.
Mary runs a small gift shop that puts about $22,000 a year in her pocket. She has not otherwise worked outside the home during the marriage.
They own four properties, none of them rented out, all bought during the marriage for the family to use:
- The family home, worth $1,500,000 with a $250,000 mortgage
- A ski chalet, worth $780,000 with a $150,000 mortgage
- A lake cottage, worth $880,000 with a $180,000 mortgage
- A summer house in PEI, worth $480,000, mortgage free
Plus cash, GICs, bonds, mutual funds, a stock account, and RRSPs on both sides.
Add it all up, net of mortgages, and they’re worth just over $7.3 million.
The tax nobody has paid
Here’s the first thing that gets missed.
Only one property in Canada gets the principal residence exemption. The family home is covered. The chalet, the cottage and the PEI house are not. Every dollar those three have gained since they were bought is a taxable capital gain, and that tax is owing the day any of them is sold.

Across those three properties there’s roughly $312,500 of capital gains tax sitting inside the numbers. The mutual funds and the stock account carry more. The RRSPs and the pension carry a great deal more, because none of that money has ever been taxed at all.
Total tax buried in a $7.3 million estate: about $1.4 million.
That’s not a technicality. It’s nearly a fifth of everything they own, and it belongs to the Canada Revenue Agency rather than to either of them. Any division that treats an RRSP dollar, a cottage dollar and a GIC dollar as the same dollar is dividing something that doesn’t exist.
Done properly, the tax-adjusted estate is about $5.9 million, and an even split gives each of them roughly $2.95 million.
Andrew’s offer
Mary keeps the family home and the ski chalet. Andrew keeps the cottage and the PEI house. The financial accounts are split so the tax-adjusted halves come out even, with Andrew paying Mary an equalization payment of about $156,500 over five years.
He also offers spousal support of $4,000 a month for five years.
His reasoning, which he means sincerely: they’re worth more than seven million dollars, she’s getting half of it, and she has a business. Nobody with nearly three million dollars needs more than that.
What the offer does to Mary
Mary’s money coming in, year one: $22,000 from the shop, $31,300 from the equalization instalment, and $48,000 of spousal support, which is taxable to her and nets about $32,600. Call it $85,900.
Now her costs. The family home and the chalet between them carry roughly $43,000 a year in mortgage payments. Property taxes, insurance, utilities and maintenance on two substantial properties, plus her actual living expenses, run about $123,000. Call it $166,000 going out.
She is short $80,000 in her first year.

In year six the spousal support and the equalization instalments both stop, and her income falls off a cliff. She goes from $85,900 a year to about $25,500.
Her cash, GICs and bonds are gone by 61. After that she draws on her RRSP, and because those withdrawals are taxed she has to pull out roughly $1.67 for every dollar she can spend.
Her savings are empty at 63.
She still owns two properties worth well over two million dollars. She cannot eat them, and selling either one triggers the tax.
Meanwhile Andrew’s cash flow is positive by about $44,200 in his first year, and once the support and equalization payments end it jumps to roughly $170,000 a year.
Second try: more support, and the chalet goes
Raise the support to $10,000 a month for ten years, and have Mary sell the ski chalet in year three.
Selling the chalet does two things. It puts about $530,000 in her account after the mortgage, the selling costs and $114,000 of capital gains tax. And it takes roughly $34,000 a year of mortgage and carrying costs off her books permanently.
That’s a genuine improvement. Her savings peak near $2.7 million in her early sixties instead of hitting zero.
But it still doesn’t hold. When support ends at 62 her income drops back to about $30,000 while her costs keep climbing, and she spends the next twenty years drawing down. Her money runs out at 82.

Third try: support that matches the marriage
Raise the support to about $13,333 a month and run it for fourteen years, with the chalet still sold in year three.
Now it works. Mary’s cash flow is close to break-even while support runs, her savings build to roughly $3.7 million, and she reaches her eighties with money still in the account.
Two things are worth saying honestly about this version.
The first is that even $160,000 a year sits at the lower end of what the Spousal Support Advisory Guidelines would produce for a 30-year marriage with this income gap. Andrew’s original offer of $48,000 was not slightly conservative. It was a fraction of the range his own lawyer would have quoted him. I don’t set that number and I don’t advise on it. But it’s worth knowing that the financial analysis and the legal guidelines point in the same direction here, which is not always the case.
The second is that this version genuinely hurts Andrew, and that matters.

Andrew plans to retire at 66, which is eleven years out. Fourteen years of support means that for the last two or three years he’s paying $160,000 a year out of a pension income, not a salary. His cash flow goes to roughly negative $150,000. He’d be funding his ex-wife’s support out of his share of the property.
That’s the kind of thing you want to discover on a chart rather than in year twelve. It might mean stepping the support down as he approaches retirement, or front-loading it, or trading a lump sum against a shorter term. Those are real options, and none of them are visible until somebody projects the thing.
What this case teaches
Tax is not a detail at this level, it’s a fifth of the estate. Registered money, second properties and appreciated investments all carry tax that hasn’t been paid. Ontario calculations adjust for it, but the adjustment only works if somebody actually gathers the adjusted cost base on every property and account. That’s homework, and it’s frequently skipped.
The principal residence exemption covers one property. If you own a cottage, a chalet, a rental or a place down south, only one of them is sheltered. Which one you claim can be worth six figures, and it’s a decision worth taking advice on rather than assuming.
Real estate is a cost centre. Four properties nobody rents out produce zero income and consume a great deal. Mary’s two properties were costing her about $76,000 a year to keep before she spent a dollar on herself. A portfolio like that is a lifestyle funded by an income, and when the income goes, the portfolio becomes a liability very quickly.
Wealth delays the problem, it doesn’t prevent it. Because there was so much money, nobody thought Mary could be in trouble. She had nearly three million dollars. She still ran out at 63, because the money produced nothing and the property consumed everything. Size is not the same as sustainability.
A settlement that breaks the payor isn’t a settlement either. The third scenario fixed Mary’s problem by creating one for Andrew. A real answer accounts for both sides, which is exactly why modelling both people matters.
Is there a large estate and an offer on the table?
A settlement analysis shows what it does to both of you, year by year, before you sign.
Where the analysis fits
This is the work I do as a Certified Divorce Financial Analyst, and it runs two ways.
Working for one spouse. Most often I’m retained by one person. You’ve been handed an offer like Andrew’s, the numbers are large enough that it feels churlish to question it, and you can’t tell whether it actually works. You’re my client, and the report is yours and your lawyer’s to use.
Working with a couple in mediation. The second way is with both of you together. One analysis, one set of assumptions, both futures side by side. Mary can see where she runs out. Andrew can see what fourteen years of support does to his retirement. They can then trade against each other knowingly, which is the only kind of settlement that holds.
I don’t decide what spousal support should be, I don’t value pensions, and I don’t do your tax return. Those belong to your lawyer, the plan administrator and your accountant. What I do is take all of those numbers and show you what each combination of them produces, year by year, for both of you.

Ask us a question
Have a question about your situation?
Send it to us and we’ll reply within one business day. No call needed, and there’s no obligation.
Ask your questionWe reply Monday to Friday. Questions sent on a weekend or holiday get an answer the next business day.
Reading keeps you informed. Talking helps you feel better.
If you’ve read everything and still don’t know your next step, let’s talk it through in a free, no-pressure call.
Common questions
How is capital gains tax handled when we divide property in Ontario?
Usually by reducing each asset’s value by the tax a sale would trigger, though how much to deduct is often contested
Assets are usually brought into the net family property calculation at a value that reflects the tax that would be owing if they were sold, often called a notional disposition cost. How much to deduct, and whether to deduct it at all when no sale is planned, is genuinely contested and depends on the asset and the circumstances. It is a point worth taking advice on, because on a portfolio of properties the difference runs well into six figures.
We own a cottage as well as a house. Can both be tax free?
No. Only one property per family can be sheltered by the principal residence exemption in any one year
No. The principal residence exemption applies to one property per family per year. You can choose which property to designate, and for years where both were owned the choice can be split, but only one can be sheltered at a time. Where you have owned both for a long time, the decision about which to designate is worth getting proper tax advice on before anything is sold.
My spouse says I’m getting millions, so I don’t need much support. Is that a fair argument?
Not on its own. Property division settles what you own, while spousal support deals with income
It’s a common one, and it confuses two different questions. Property division settles what you own. Spousal support addresses income and the difference in earning capacity built up during the marriage. A large share of property that produces no income does not replace an income, and the projections usually make that obvious very quickly.
Should I keep the cottage?
Only after you know what it costs you each year and what it brings in
Work out what it costs annually and what it produces. If the answer is tens of thousands going out and nothing coming in, keeping it is a lifestyle decision being funded from capital. That may be exactly what you want. It should be a choice made with the figure in front of you rather than something that happens because nobody asked.
What about the tax on RRSPs and pensions?
Neither has been taxed yet, so a registered dollar is worth less than a dollar in savings
Neither has ever been taxed. A $600,000 RRSP is not the same as $600,000 in a savings account, and a pension’s Family Law Value is a pre-tax number as well. Splitting registered and non-registered assets at face value quietly gives one spouse considerably less than the other.
Does a high net worth case need a different approach?
The method is the same, but there’s more hidden tax, more valuation questions and more professionals involved
The method is the same but the stakes and the complexity are higher. More asset classes, more embedded tax, more valuation questions, and usually an accountant and a business or pension valuator involved alongside the lawyers. What doesn’t change is that the size of the estate tells you nothing about whether the settlement works.
Questions about how a settlement analysis works, who it’s for and what you need to bring are answered on our settlement analysis page.
Ken S. Maynard
- APFM - Association of Private Family Mediators Canada
- CDFA - Certified Divorce Financial Analyst
- Member, Association of Family and Conciliation Courts (AFCC)
- Member, Family Dispute Resolution Institute of Ontario (FDRIO)
I help intelligent, successful couples move through separation without getting pulled into the adversarial legal system. Together we craft a custom separation agreement that sets you up for a secure future and a smooth transition to the next chapter.
Many couples reach a complete agreement in about four meetings. Others need more time, and that's fine. The pace is set by your situation, not by a formula. Either way, you sidestep most of the conflict, confusion, and cost that come with going through the courts.
You can work with me by video conference or meet in person with a DTSW associate at any of our six Greater Toronto mediation centres in Aurora, Barrie, North York, Vaughan, Mississauga, and Scarborough.













































